A criminal history check answers one question: was this person arrested or convicted? That is useful, but it is a narrow question. When a client asks whether something happened in the past, a clean criminal history may not tell the whole story.
Some serious matters never produce a criminal record. Allegations involving families are a good example. They are often handled through child protective agencies or family court, which are civil systems. A case can be investigated, a file can be opened, and a court can issue orders without anyone ever being charged. If the only thing you searched was a criminal database, you search is limited.
Where records actually live
- Court clerk. Docket and index entries often exist even when the file itself is sealed or archived. A docket number alone can be a significant find.
- Child protective or social services agency. These agencies keep their own case files, separate from any court.
- Police agencies. Incident and complaint reports exist without arrests, and they will not show up in a criminal history.
- Medical and school records. Pediatricians, emergency rooms, school nurses, and counselors document things that no court ever sees.
- Prior counsel or a court-appointed representative. Their files can outlast the court’s own.
Confidential is not the same as unavailable
Family court and child welfare records are usually confidential, not public. That means a PI or a member of the public generally cannot walk in and ask for them without a waiver from the subject showing “good cause.” If there are other inidividuals in the record, the file will have to be redacted to remain only specific to your client or a motion to unseal/release for “good cause” must be submitted by an attorney. The rules differ by state and even by county, so confirm them before promising anything.
Retention changes the answer
Courts and agencies do not keep everything forever. Many files are archived or destroyed after a set number of years, and unfounded or unsubstantiated reports are often expunged much sooner. After several decades, “no record found” can simply mean “no record kept.” It tells you nothing about what did or did not happen.
Setting expectations
When we take on an old records search, I tell the client up front that an exhaustive search could lead to a complete file, a partial record, or nothing. All three are results. We report what we found, name the sources, and state plainly what we could not confirm without guess work.
Key Takeaway
A criminal record check answers one question. Whether something happened is a different question, and the answer often sits in records you cannot search online by name. Knowing which records exist, who holds them, and who has standing to request them is what separates a thorough search from a surface one; however, access is still not guaranteed.
A presto!
