A client came to us convinced someone was watching their home. They reported that a vehicle sat out front of their house at irregular times over an extended period. They called the local police several times and never heard back on the referral. The client wanted to know who this was and why the person was there. It’s a fair question, and it’s the kind of case we take.

From there, our team moved forward in identifying the vehicle and the person, which included a historical background for situational awareness and safety. A plan was created for surveillance and a field investigative interview. However, before we implemented our plan, the client walked out and confronted the person themself.

It turned out the parked vehicle was there for an ordinary reason that had nothing to do with the client. The person turned out to be harmless, but the client didn’t know that beforehand, and neither did we. The client walked up to a stranger they believed was stalking them, with no backup and no plan. The answer was benign, but it could just as easily not have been.

I’ve seen the same pattern in other cases. People are scared, frustrated, or tired of waiting, and they start investigating on their own. Three habits do the most damage:

1. Confronting the other party. You lose the element of surprise, you give them time to prepare a story, and you may hand them a complaint to file against you. A planned interview by trained people is a controlled setting. A driveway confrontation is not, and if the person is actually dangerous, you’ve put yourself in front of them alone.

2. Posting on social media during a case. Every post is potential evidence, and the other side’s attorney will read it. Vacation photos in an injury claim, venting about the other party in a custody matter, a “good day” post during a disability case. Posts get screenshotted, and deleting them later can create its own problems.

3. Recording without understanding the law. New York is a one-party consent state, but a call or meeting that crosses into another state can fall under stricter rules. For example, Virginia, Maryland, and D.C. each handle consent differently. An illegal recording can be excluded and can expose you to liability, so check before you hit record.

The common thread is simple. Evidence only helps you if it was gathered the right way. A good investigation is built to be safe, documented, and usable later. DIY efforts are usually none of those. If you feel something is wrong, write down what you see, keep a timeline, and call a licensed investigator or law enforcement before you act.

Let a trained professional handle the situation safely. Getting involved on your own can turn against you quickly.

A presto!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *